Only Willie Nelson could have a “campus ban” rumor stick for 40 years and make him look even more like the cowboy rebel everyone loves.

If you’ve ever cracked open a cold one on your porch with “Whiskey River” on the radio, you know the Red-Headed Stranger didn’t get crowned king of outlaw country by playing it safe. The man’s made a career out of crossing lines, from lighting up on the roof of the White House to penning songs too raw for country radio back when “controversial” meant you didn’t get played in church parking lots. So when Baylor University canceled Willie’s benefit gig back in 1988, the story practically wrote itself. But did they really ban him for life, or did the legend just outrun the rumor?

Young Willie Nelson once walked Baylor’s halls, studying agriculture in the 1950s before dropping out to chase a guitar string that would lead him to every neon dive bar from Texas to Tennessee. Flash forward to 1988, and you’ve got Willie at the peak of his fame, lined up to headline a fundraiser for folks who’d lost everything when a bank in Leroy, Texas, went belly up. By then, Willie was fresh off his Farm Aid success, having raised millions for America’s family farmers alongside Neil Young and John Mellencamp. The man could sell a benefit gig in his sleep.

Except Baylor’s bigwigs got cold feet. In an interview that’s lived on like a ghost story, university spokesman Eugene Baker said the quiet part out loud. The school didn’t want Willie’s “activities” rubbing off on students. Read between the lines, and you know they were talking about his green habit. Baker said Willie “has had great opportunity to be a positive influence,” but just “has not availed himself of this particular opportunity.” Translation? They didn’t want a pot-loving, guitar-picking poet teaching their kids how to roll one up between hymnals.

In true outlaw fashion, Willie shrugged and went back to doing what he does best, taking his show anywhere that’d have him. Baylor students, meanwhile, have spent decades trying to figure out if the ban is real or just a piece of Texas folklore. A student op-ed last fall titled “Baylor, it’s time to free Willie” made the rounds while petitions have popped up like wildflowers after a Hill Country rainstorm. The university’s latest spin is they’re “not aware” of any official ban, which is pretty on-brand for a story that probably started as a whisper and turned into a campfire tale.

Now in his 90s, Willie doesn’t seem to lose sleep over Baylor’s moral panic. The man’s too busy dropping new records, showing up at Farm Aid, and cooking up cannabis cookbooks with his wife Annie. If anything, getting “banned” from campus is just another notch on the outlaw belt, including IRS battles, smoke sessions on the roof, and decades of sticking it to the Nashville suits.

At the end of the day, the myth is bigger than the truth, and that’s just how Willie likes it. Maybe one day Baylor will open its gates wide and give the Red-Headed Stranger the hero’s welcome he deserves. But you get the feeling Willie wouldn’t bother to show up anyway. He’s got songs to write, guitars to tune, and a joint to roll by the campfire while the rest of us tell stories about the time he was too much outlaw for a Texas college to handle.